The State of the Public Sector Construction Industry : Challenges & Strategic Shifts …

posted in: General 0

The State of the Public Sector Construction Industry: Challenges and Strategic Shifts
The South African Public Sector of the Construction industry has always been shaped by the rhythms of government procurement, but in recent months, a storm has been brewing. A sharp decline in public sector activity is threatening the stability of many contractors, and as someone deeply embedded in the industry, I’ve witnessed these changes firsthand. It’s a landscape in flux, one that demands we all rethink how we approach the market. The public sector’s shifting priorities, changes in tendering processes, and internal political developments are altering the course of construction in South Africa, and those who fail to adapt may find themselves left behind.

A Declining Trend in Public Sector Projects
Since March 2024, I’ve observed a worrying trend in the public sector construction industry. Activity has significantly declined, and this shift is largely driven by changes in government tender advertisements. When I say government, I mean all state entities, including parastatals like SANRAL, Eskom, and the Department of Public Works, etc. At Leads 2 Business, where we monitor the pulse of the market, the signs have been clear: from 2022, we began to notice a significant reduction in tenders, particularly those within the CIDB 8 and 9GB categories. And the situation has only worsened through 2023, with multiple tenders being recalled or withdrawn, especially from key players like SANRAL.

This trend has had a profound impact on contractors, especially those specializing in Civil Engineering (CE) work. What’s more concerning is that, despite our best efforts to stay ahead of the curve, the reasons behind these changes remain opaque. However, we’ve been able to adjust our Private Projects Research strategy to assist our subcontractor client, in response, as the Private Projects Department we shifted our focus to follow public projects with CIDB 7 CE/GB ratings in addition to the larger CIDB 8 and 9GB ones. This move has given our subcontractor subscriber a much-needed reprieve, preventing them from fighting over the diminishing pool of high-tier tenders.

The New Normal: A Slowdown in Public Sector Projects
But now, as we move into 2025, the situation has taken a dramatic turn. The formation of the Government of National Unity (GNU) after the elections has shaken up the public procurement landscape. While the transition to a new government was necessary, it’s caused significant disruptions in the tendering process. Project managers I’ve spoken with from the Department of Public Works and the KZN Department of Health shared how internal delays, ranging from the filling of new leadership roles to budget realignments have stalled projects. Simply put, the wheels of government procurement have screeched to a temporal halt.

What does this mean for contractors? With the political reshuffling and changes in governance, projects that were previously on track behind the scenes have come to an abrupt stop. Prices have shifted, contracts can no longer be signed at the same tender rates, and there’s uncertainty about when projects will resume towards being publicly issued as tenders. The knock-on effect is a noticeable slowdown in tender as well as project construction activity on ground since June 2024, and I fear that this is just the beginning of a long, lean period for public sector contractors.

The Rise of Panel Tendering: A New Challenge
A notable trend that has emerged, particularly in my region of focus, Gauteng, is the shift toward panel contracting. This is a fairly new approach where government departments now opt for a panel of pre-qualified contractors who are invited to tender for specific tender contracts. While this may seem like a streamlined and efficient method, it creates several challenges for contractors:

Limited Access: Contractors who are not part of the panel are shut out of these opportunities. The panel system can last for up to three years before  new contractors are invited, effectively locking out many players from participating in these projects.
Lack of Transparency: Since tenders are not publicly advertised, smaller subcontractors and contractors who are not on the panel miss out on opportunities. There’s no public listing of these projects, and information is kept private within the select group of approved contractors.
Rising Barriers to Entry: For contractors aiming to grow their CIDB rating and secure larger projects, the panel system presents a significant challenge. Those who weren’t able to meet the panel requirements in the past are effectively sidelined for the next few years, exacerbating the struggles of emerging contractors.

How Leads 2 Business Helps in Navigating These Changes
At Leads 2 Business, we’ve always prided ourselves on being more than just an information platform. Our mission is to ensure our subscribers stay ahead of the curve, even in uncertain times. As the public sector procurement system shifts, we’ve adapted our strategies to help contractors and vendors continue to thrive.

We have a unique advantage: The ecosystem of our company is integrated in such a way that we gain insights into panel-based tenders and projects, even when they’re not publicly advertised. As many of our esteemed clients sit on these panels, we’re able to access pricing data from pricing requests facilitated through our Leads 2 Quotes pricing platform: a platform engineered to connect the contractor to relevant supplier/vendor in relevant regions of the tender. By tracking these quotations, we can flag relevant public sector tenders and projects that are now not typically advertised by traditional bidding procurement methods.

This approach gives our supplier, manufacture and vendor subscriber the opportunity to see if their products are being priced for panel- based contracts, and this feature also provides our contractor subscriber a competitive edge. By sourcing multiple quotes from our database, contractors can ensure their bids are at more competitive rates.

Why This Matters: Adapting to a Changing Market
The construction industry is going through a significant transformation as it always has and will continue to do, and as someone deeply involved in the space, I can confidently say that the only way to survive and thrive in this environment is to stay ahead of the changes. For contractors and the rest of the construction industry players relying on public sector work, the slowdown in publicly available tenders, the rise of panel systems, and the political shifts pose considerable challenges. But by leveraging our system as a tool, you can remain agile, informed, and competitive.

As the industry evolves, it’s crucial that we all keep adapting, learning, and preparing for the changes ahead. The public sector might be in a period of flux, but with the right tools, insights, and strategies, the opportunities will always be there, waiting for those who are prepared to seize them.

The state of the public sector construction industry is undeniably turbulent, but the opportunities for those who can navigate these changes are still abundant. By staying informed, adapting to the new tendering processes, and using Leads 2 Business as a tool, contractors, suppliers, consultants, vendors and manufacturers can not only survive but thrive in the face of these challenges. The future of the construction industry in South Africa is not set in stone, but with the right insights and strategies, we can shape it together.

If you are a valued Projects subscriber, you can find more details about this Featured Project here.
If you are interested in becoming one of our subscribers, please visit our website.
To view notes with screenshots on how to use our website, please visit our Wiki site.
To view more articles, please visit our blog.

About Minnie Zondi

I am an insanely optimistic ambivert that does everything from the heart instead of the mind. Deeply interested in people and matters that pertain to mankind.

Featured Company: Dewpoint Industries

Read about who’s who in the Industry:  Dewpoint Industries has gone from strength to strength as their temporary surface protection product range has grown into one of the largest available in the country. They make use of a wide range of expertise, always working to improve and develop more solutions for their loyal client base. Their growing team is currently spearheading Dewpoint’s expansion and servicing clients nationally.

Dewpoint Industries

If you are interested in becoming one of our subscribers, please visit Leads 2 Business.
To view notes with screenshots on how to use our website, please visit Leads 2 Business Wiki.
To view more Featured Companies, please visit our Leads 2 Business Blog.

About Michelle Herbst

I started working at Leads 2 Business in February 2014. I'm a Senior L2Q Account Executive for the Cape Town Region.

Navigating New Procurement Rules and Their Impact

In the complex world of tenders and procurement, every action triggers a reaction, and recent developments have certainly set the stage for significant change.

The South African National Roads Agency (SANRAL) has recently made headlines with the suspension of its Chief Financial Officer and Head of Supply Chain Management. Allegedly, these suspensions are tied to concerns about the new procurement policy that the SANRAL Board introduced in May 2023. This policy brought about a noteworthy shift by placing greater emphasis on factors such as black ownership and subcontracting.

Traditionally, SANRAL used a bidder’s B-BBEE rating to assign 10 or 20 points to assess compliance with the State-Owned Enterprise’s preferential procurement requirements. Companies achieving a Level 1 B-BBEE rating, the highest and most sought-after empowerment status, were automatically granted the maximum points. However, in May, SANRAL revamped the scoring system, elevating the importance of black ownership and subcontracting. Under this new system, black ownership and subcontracting now account for five points (or 10 points in the case of an 80/20 scoring model) and four points (or eight points in the case of an 80/20 model), respectively, in tenders using the 90/10 scoring regime. This change effectively diminishes a bidder’s B-BBEE rating to just one point for a 90/10 tender (valued at over R50 million) or two points for an 80/20 tender (valued between R30,000 and R50 million). SANRAL, however, staunchly defends its new tender scoring system, citing its commitment to constitutional economic transformation and its goal to foster growth among black-owned construction companies, thereby improving their CIDB grading and advancing 100% black-owned firms within the construction industry.

The South African construction sector, which has invested billions over the past decade to enhance its empowerment profiles and engage with the government, finds itself facing unique challenges. This industry, now only 20% of its former size due to economic weaknesses, is grappling with turbulence. For instance, in July, construction firm Haw & Inglis (H&I) secured an interdict preventing SANRAL from awarding two tenders for which H&I had submitted bids. In a follow-up application, supported by WBHO and 11 other construction companies, including Raubex and Stefanutti Stocks, H&I has challenged the new scoring system on the grounds that it was implemented without proper consultation and is unconstitutional and irrational. In response, SANRAL maintains that it had the authority to modify the scoring criteria and that the list in the act was not exhaustive. Asithandile Ben-Mazwi, the Acting Head of Supply Chain Management, emphasized that it falls within the prerogative of state entities to determine criteria and their relative weights in tender documents. SANRAL asserts that its decision to abandon the previous scoring system in favor of the new one was made after careful consideration, grounded in legislative and policy considerations. Additionally, SANRAL argues that if the courts side with the construction firms, it could signify an overreach of judicial authority.

Meanwhile, on a different front, the National Treasury has presented a new Public Procurement Bill to Parliament, which opened for public comments last week. This bill seeks to revamp the preferential procurement system by allowing for the implementation of “one or more preference points systems.” It also permits certain contracts to be earmarked for designated groups to promote localization and subcontracting. Stakeholders are encouraged to submit written feedback on the bill by 11 September 2023. The bill’s summary highlights the fragmentation of public procurement regulations across various laws governing public administration in South Africa.

Sources:
Daily Maverick
IOL
News24


To view more Articles, please visit our Leads 2 Business Blog.
If you are interested in becoming one of our subscribers, please visit Leads 2 Business.
To view notes with screenshots on how to use our website, please visit Leads 2 Business Wiki.

About Debbie Wessels

I started at Leads 2 Business in April 2008 in the tenders Department and transferred to the Projects Department during the same year. I was appointed Head of Department for Projects from February 2011 to March 2022. April 2022 I started a new adventure as Content Regulator.